Published: October 27, 2025 | Updated: October 23, 2025
Published: October 27, 2025 | Updated: October 23, 2025
Wheeled vs. Tracked Equipment: Maintenance Costs and CMMS Benefits
When companies weigh the purchase of heavy equipment, the conversation usually starts with upfront costs and performance specs. Yet maintenance, operating life, and resale value shape the true return on investment. Let's look at choosing between wheeled and tracked equipment with factors such as maintenance costs and insights regarding a computerized maintenance management system. The comparison between wheeled and tracked equipment highlights how different machines demand different levels of care. A CMMS adds an extra dimension, offering a framework for reducing costs and extending asset value across an entire fleet.
When companies weigh the purchase of heavy equipment, the conversation often begins with upfront costs and performance specifications. However, factors such as maintenance, operating life, and resale value ultimately determine the true return on investment. Choosing between wheeled and tracked equipment requires evaluating maintenance costs and understanding how a computerized maintenance management system (CMMS) can influence long-term efficiency. A CMMS introduces a structured approach to maintenance, reducing costs and extending the value of assets across an entire fleet.
Understanding Equipment Maintenance Costs Beyond the Purchase Price
Buying heavy machinery represents one of the largest capital expenses in industries like construction, mining, agriculture, and energy. Yet the full financial picture only becomes clear over the years of ownership. Preventive maintenance, inspections, and unplanned repairs all contribute to the total cost of ownership.
For instance, a mid-sized construction firm reported over $1.2 million annually in repair and downtime expenses across its excavator fleet. After implementing a CMMS, it shifted to proactive maintenance and reduced those costs by nearly 20% in two years. This example demonstrates how data-driven maintenance strategies can impact profitability just as much as smart purchasing decisions.
Maintenance Needs: Complex vs. Simplified Equipment
Some machines have higher maintenance demands because of intricate mechanical systems. Bulldozers and excavators rely on hydraulic systems, engines, and track assemblies that need frequent lubrication and part replacement. Cranes have cables, pulleys, and hydraulic lifts that require regular inspection to ensure safety compliance.
In contrast, backhoes, skid steers, and compactors generally have fewer moving parts, resulting in lower maintenance intensity. However, even these machines benefit from systematic care. A CMMS can automate lubrication alerts, spare parts tracking, and inspection schedules—helping ensure no machine is overlooked.
Discover how streamlined maintenance processes can elevate production. Learn more.
Comparing Equipment Maintenance Strategies and Costs
Preventive Maintenance
Scheduled inspections and servicing help manage wear and tear before major failures occur. While preventive maintenance increases short-term costs, it prevents catastrophic breakdowns. For example, replacing hydraulic seals for $1,500 is far cheaper than repairing a full hydraulic pump failure costing $40,000 and two weeks of downtime. CMMS systems track service histories and schedules to demonstrate cost savings and prevent recurrence.
Predictive Maintenance
Using IoT sensors, vibration monitoring, and telematics, predictive maintenance identifies potential issues before they cause failures. Mining companies, for instance, monitor haul trucks with these systems. Detecting tire pressure or gear vibration anomalies can prevent downtime valued at $250,000 per hour. CMMS platforms integrate this sensor data, creating accurate records of conditions and responses.
Condition-Based Maintenance
Condition-based maintenance relies on real-time monitoring. Instead of fixed service intervals, maintenance happens only when performance thresholds are exceeded. Although initial setup costs are higher, this strategy is ideal in industries like oil drilling or aerospace, where failure is not an option.
Breakdown and Repair Maintenance
This strategy is the most expensive because it leads to cascading costs, including labor, replacement parts, lost productivity, and safety hazards. One logistics company lost $500,000 in shipping revenue after an unexpected container handler failure. CMMS systems reduce reliance on this reactive approach by reinforcing preventive and predictive maintenance plans.
Key Drivers Behind Equipment Maintenance Costs
Several factors influence maintenance costs, such as:
- Equipment age – Older assets need more frequent repairs and hard-to-find parts.
- Operating conditions – Mining equipment in abrasive environments experiences higher wear rates.
- Labor availability – In regions like Canada’s oil sands, technician shortages drive up labor costs.
- Downtime impact – A crane breakdown at a high-rise site can delay multiple subcontractors.
- Fuel and compliance – New emissions regulations require extra filters and monitoring.
By analyzing these variables, CMMS tools identify cost patterns and support smarter budgeting and purchasing decisions.
Wheeled vs. Tracked Equipment: Maintenance and Lifecycle Costs
Tracked Equipment
Tracked machines excel in off-road performance and durability. Their wide tracks distribute weight evenly, offering excellent traction on mud, snow, and gravel. Sectors like forestry and pipeline construction rely on tracked dozers and excavators for stability in soft terrain. However, maintenance is more expensive—track replacements cost $30,000–$40,000 and are needed every 3,000–5,000 hours. Tracks also wear down paved roads faster, limiting urban versatility. A CMMS can log usage hours, prompt inspections, and forecast replacements to prevent surprise expenses.
Wheeled Equipment
Wheeled machines offer agility, faster travel, and lower upfront maintenance. Wheel loaders, backhoes, and dump trucks perform well on paved surfaces and long hauls, with tire replacements costing about $5,000–$10,000 per set. However, wheels underperform in soft or unstable conditions. Urban contractors prefer wheeled models for mobility, while mining operations rely on tracked machines for stability. A CMMS enables cost-per-hour comparisons across mixed fleets to identify the most efficient option for each environment.
How Equipment Size and Engine Type Affect Maintenance
Larger equipment requires greater maintenance resources. A massive dragline excavator may need specialized cranes and teams, while smaller skid steers can be serviced by a few mechanics. Bigger engines consume more fuel, require frequent oil changes, and need advanced diagnostics. One mining company saved $2 million annually by using a CMMS to align engine overhauls with scheduled downtimes, preventing costly disruptions during peak production.
Spare Parts Management and CMMS
Spare parts often represent hidden maintenance expenses. Delays in sourcing components can halt entire projects. A CMMS reduces these risks by tracking inventory, flagging reorder points, comparing OEM versus aftermarket parts, and providing visibility across locations. A rental company that adopted digital parts management through CMMS reduced downtime incidents by eliminating 40% of service delays previously caused by missing parts.
Seasonal and Environmental Factors in Maintenance Planning
Weather and environmental conditions heavily impact maintenance requirements:
- Spring – Full inspections and fluid checks after winter storage.
- Summer – Heat increases fluid degradation and tire wear; dust clogs filters.
- Fall – Rain promotes corrosion; protective storage is essential.
- Winter – Cold weather affects fluids and batteries, causing startup issues.
Scheduling seasonal maintenance within a CMMS ensures equipment is prepared year-round, reducing environmental strain and increasing reliability.
Comparing Maintenance Costs of New vs. Older Equipment
New equipment generally comes with warranties and better fuel efficiency, reducing early maintenance costs. However, higher purchase prices stretch budgets. Older machines require frequent service, consume more fuel, and may have obsolete parts. A leasing company used a CMMS to compare total lifecycle costs and discovered that while older assets were cheaper upfront, they were more expensive long term. This insight informed smarter purchasing policies based on lifecycle value, not sticker price.
The Role of CMMS in Asset Lifecycle Management
A CMMS extends asset life by tracking total ownership costs from purchase to resale, identifying underperforming equipment, integrating compliance inspections, and offering dashboards that inform retirement or replacement decisions.
The Future of Equipment Maintenance
Investing in Maintenance Intelligence
The debate over wheeled versus tracked machines will persist, driven by job conditions and budgets. However, the future of equipment management lies in how organizations handle maintenance itself. By embedding CMMS solutions into operations, companies move from reactive fixes to proactive, data-driven lifecycle management. Success in heavy industries will increasingly depend not on horsepower—but on maintenance intelligence and data insights.
FAQs
What is the difference between wheeled and tracked equipment in terms of maintenance costs?
Wheeled equipment generally has lower maintenance costs, while tracked equipment offers durability but requires more expensive upkeep like track replacements.
How does a CMMS help reduce heavy equipment maintenance costs?
A CMMS lowers costs by scheduling preventive maintenance, tracking parts, and minimizing downtime.
Why should companies consider MAPCON’s CMMS for equipment management?
MAPCON’s CMMS provides fleet-wide visibility, spare parts tracking, and predictive maintenance tools that reduce unexpected breakdowns.
What factors most affect heavy equipment maintenance expenses?
Age, operating conditions, labor costs, downtime impact, and compliance requirements are the biggest drivers.
Can CMMS improve the lifespan of wheeled and tracked equipment?
Yes, by ensuring timely servicing, inspections, and usage tracking, CMMS extends asset life and boosts resale value.
Is preventive maintenance more cost-effective than breakdown repairs?
Yes, preventive maintenance costs less in the long run by avoiding major failures and downtime.
MAPCON | 800-922-4336
MAPCON CMMS software empowers you to plan and execute PM tasks flawlessly, thanks to its wealth of features and customizable options. Want to see it for yourself? Click the button below to get your FREE 30-day trial of MAPCON!
Try It FREE!